Sea-Watch prepares legal measures to enforce the Non-Refoulement Principle

2 min read

Photo: Sea-Watch / Copyright

Sea-Watch has demanded of the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague to extend the ongoing investigation of human rights violations in Libya to the activities of the Libyan Coast Guard. Most concerning is the forced return of migrants to Libya, documented by Sea-Watch yet again in an incident last week which constitutes a violation of international law. A swift take-up of investigations could prevent further serious crimes.

“The conditions in Libya’s camps, some of which are led by militia and self-proclaimed warlords, are known: extortion, torture, and sexual exploitation are common. The German Foreign Office has recently stated that there is no legal administration in Libya. It is therefore imperative to penalize serious violations by the international community. The ICC is the only authority that could become active here,” says lawyer Jens Janssen.

“The Mediterranean is the deadliest border in the world. If someone risks the dangerous crossing to Europe, then only because Libya’s disastrous conditions are even more life threatening. One cannot send people back to a country where they face rape and imprisonment. This does not only violate the non-refoulement principle of the Geneva Refugee Convention, but also goes against any sense of humanity,” says CEO Axel Grafmanns.

 

Background

During the incident on May 10th 2017, members of the Libyan Coast Guard obstructed a rescue operation by the Crew of Sea-Watch 2 who was sent by the Maritime Rescue Coordination Center (MRCC) to help a wooden boat in distress at 19 Nautical Miles off the coast, outside of Libyan territorial waters. The Libyan Captain forced the migrants to return to Tripoli with the Patrol vessel, pointing a gun at them.

“It is not the first time that Sea-Watch documents how people are forced back to Libyan shores against their will. Within territorial waters, they can violate international law just like they do on land. But this refoulement from the contiguous zone clearly breaches the Non-Refoulement Principle of the Geneva Refugee Convention”, says Grafmanns. Any intervention of the authorities in the contiguous zone concerning migrating boat people cannot be justified by Libyan rights to control economic infringements like oil smuggling or illegal fishing. Interception and redirection of migrants are never “necessary” practices for investigating violations of Libyan law.

In her study of the Principle of Non-Refoulement, Seline Trevisanut, Professor of International Law at Utrecht University, states: “The protection of a minor interest, as preventing a violation of its migration law, does not justify any kind of intervention. […] Consequently, once the coastal state exercises its jurisdictional powers intercepting and redirecting the vessel, it must consider whether its action may put the passengers of the concerned vessel at risk of persecution, torture or other inhuman treatments. The need of proportionality emerges in relation to the operations accomplished by states authorities on the high seas for contrasting unlawful migration.”

 


video footage Raoul Kopacka

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ONWduazMDpo

 

 

More news

All news

Press Release

First Justice Fleet anniversary: major court wins for the new alliance

One year ago, 13 civilian search and rescue organisations cut all operational contact with the Libyan rescue coordination centre in Tripoli, thereby founding the Justice Fleet Alliance. Since then, their rescue ships were blocked 12 times by the Italian government, amounting to more than 300 days of lost operational time. However, Italian courts confirm the alliance's approach: six times, Italian courts set the ships free again shortly after their detention. Six additional blockades are under judicial procedure at the moment, and the alliance is awaiting their verdicts. While some legal proceedings are still ongoing, none has resulted in a final ruling against Justice Fleet members.

Press Release

2026 is the most violent year in the Mediterranean since 2016

A new report by the civil sea rescue organisation Sea-Watch documents 107 violent incidents by Libyan militias against migrants and refugees, as well as European actors in the Mediterranean since 2016. More than 70 per cent of these incidents of extreme violence, 80 in total, were carried out by the so-called Libyan coastguard. The report is being published shortly before the renewal of Germany’s EUNAVFOR MED IRINI mandate. The current version of the mandate contains no clause excluding the training of the so-called Libyan Coast Guard by the German armed forces (Bundeswehr).

Press Release

Frontex ignores rescue ship - but gives Libyan militia the coordinates of a boat in distress

A Frontex aircraft ignored repeated radio calls from the civilian rescue ship Solidaire, then promptly gave a Libyan militia the coordinates of a boat in distress, facilitating the illegal pullback of the people on board. Sea-Watch’s monitoring aircraft Seabird 2 documented the radio exchange in international waters off Libya, as well as the interception that followed. Frontex radio communications also indicate that Frontex staff share their aircraft positions via Telegram. The incident comes just one day after the European Commission proposed the largest expansion of Frontex to date.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Fields marked with * are mandatory.
Transparente Zivilgesellschaft – We are part of the Transparent Civil Society Initiative: our figures and reports
Sea-Watch e.V. – Civil sea rescue at Europe’s bordersThis site is powered by Netlify