Sea-Watch wins appeal: the Dutch State is not allowed to apply new safety requirements until the end of 2019

2 min read

Photo: Sea-Watch / Copyright

Today, a judge in The Hague ruled on the appeal lodged by Sea-Watch. The Court’s judgment acknowledges that the negative consequences of omitting a transitional period for the more stringent safety regulations on Sea-Watch’s ship, namely that people may drown due to limited rescue capacity in the Mediterranean Sea, outweigh the purpose of the new regulations. Therefore, Sea-Watch will have until 31 December 2019 to apply the new policy to its ship.

Today’s judgment also emphasises that the actions of the Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management, who imposed the new safety requirements on Sea-Watch without granting a transitional period, were unlawful and contrary to the principles of proportionality and the requirement of due diligence. The essence of the appeal was the judgment of the Court in preliminary proceedings of 7 May, in which Sea-Watch was not granted a transitional period for the application of new strict safety requirements.

The trial shows that Sea-Watch is resisting the arbitrary behaviour of states. For Sea-Watch, this is not only a victory in obtaining a transitional period for the application of changes to our ship; it is also a victory in the sense that a civil player has held a government accountable for its deadly actions.

However, this victory in the Netherlands underlines the battle that Sea-Watch is waging elsewhere. The Sea-Watch 3, is still under probationary confiscation by the Italian authorities, and there too we are fighting for its early release in order to resume our monitoring and rescue mission as soon as possible. The criminalisation of civil organisations that carry out life-saving work in the Mediterranean Sea is a systematic strategy employed by several Member States of the European Union, and in which the Netherlands is also actively involved. The fact that this new legislation is not about security but about migration policy became painfully clear earlier this year by hundreds of documents released under the Freedom of Information Act. Our opposition to the EU’s deadly policy and abuse of power continues.

More news

All news

Press Release

First Justice Fleet anniversary: major court wins for the new alliance

One year ago, 13 civilian search and rescue organisations cut all operational contact with the Libyan rescue coordination centre in Tripoli, thereby founding the Justice Fleet Alliance. Since then, their rescue ships were blocked 12 times by the Italian government, amounting to more than 300 days of lost operational time. However, Italian courts confirm the alliance's approach: six times, Italian courts set the ships free again shortly after their detention. Six additional blockades are under judicial procedure at the moment, and the alliance is awaiting their verdicts. While some legal proceedings are still ongoing, none has resulted in a final ruling against Justice Fleet members.

Press Release

2026 is the most violent year in the Mediterranean since 2016

A new report by the civil sea rescue organisation Sea-Watch documents 107 violent incidents by Libyan militias against migrants and refugees, as well as European actors in the Mediterranean since 2016. More than 70 per cent of these incidents of extreme violence, 80 in total, were carried out by the so-called Libyan coastguard. The report is being published shortly before the renewal of Germany’s EUNAVFOR MED IRINI mandate. The current version of the mandate contains no clause excluding the training of the so-called Libyan Coast Guard by the German armed forces (Bundeswehr).

Press Release

Frontex ignores rescue ship - but gives Libyan militia the coordinates of a boat in distress

A Frontex aircraft ignored repeated radio calls from the civilian rescue ship Solidaire, then promptly gave a Libyan militia the coordinates of a boat in distress, facilitating the illegal pullback of the people on board. Sea-Watch’s monitoring aircraft Seabird 2 documented the radio exchange in international waters off Libya, as well as the interception that followed. Frontex radio communications also indicate that Frontex staff share their aircraft positions via Telegram. The incident comes just one day after the European Commission proposed the largest expansion of Frontex to date.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Fields marked with * are mandatory.
Transparente Zivilgesellschaft – We are part of the Transparent Civil Society Initiative: our figures and reports
Sea-Watch e.V. – Civil sea rescue at Europe’s bordersThis site is powered by Netlify