Italy Detains Sea-Watch 5 After Crew Refuses Orders That Put Lives at Risk

By Giulia Messmer2 min read

WordPress migration:8093f56563917433Photo: Sea-Watch / Copyright

Berlin / Trapani, 30 March 2026 – Italian authorities have imposed a 20-day detention and a €10,000 fine on the civilian search-and-rescue vessel Sea-Watch 5. On March 15, the ship rescued 93 people in distress in international waters. During the rescue operation, the crew refused to communicate with Libyan militias, which return refugees to systems of arbitrary detention and torture and have repeatedly opened fire on rescue crews in the past. The crew also defied orders to proceed to a designated port more than 1,100 kilometers away. In order to safeguard the fundamental right to life (Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights), the captain declared a state of necessity on March 18 and instead headed to the nearer port of Trapani. Sea-Watch condemns the detention as a predictable measure designed to sabotage civilian sea rescue operations.

The detention order follows a rescue of 93 people on 15 March in international waters. Nine medical emergencies had to be immediately evacuated to Italy, including a two-year-old child in life-threatening condition. The Sicilian juvenile court also ordered the immediate disembarkation of 23 minors and their families.

For the remaining survivors on board, authorities denied a nearby place of safety and instead assigned the distant port of Marina di Carrara in northern Italy. Located over 1,100 kilometers away, the journey would have taken several days under adverse conditions. The survivors on board were suffering from seasickness, exhaustion, and fuel burns, which needed to be treated under proper clinical conditions. In order to protect the fundamental right to life (Article 2 of the ECHR), the captain declared the state of necessity on 18 March and entered the port of Trapani.

Sea-Watch condemns the detention. The orders are based on the so-called Piantedosi Decree, the latest in a series of legislative measures introduced by Italy in recent years to restrict civil search and rescue efforts. Crews are confronted with instructions that are incompatible with international law and humanitarian obligations. Compliance would endanger both rescued individuals and crew members; refusal, in turn, leads to sanctions.

 

Sea-Watch Spokesperson Bana Mahmood states:

“It is clear that this is not about enforcing rules but about deliberately creating new mechanisms with the aim to detain and immobilise sea rescue ships. Administrative obstruction is killing people at sea.”

Sea-Watch is part of the Justice Fleet and refuses to comply with orders that conflict with international conventions and human rights obligations and primarily serve to hinder rescue operations. In recent months, Italian courts have suspended detention orders of the Sea-Watch 5 and for other ships of the Justice Fleet, ruling in interim measures that such orders are disproportionate, including in the cases of the Humanity 1 and the Sea-Eye 5. Final rulings on the overall lawfulness are still pending.

Sea-Watch, too, will pursue legal action against the detention order.

More news

All news

Press Release

First Justice Fleet anniversary: major court wins for the new alliance

One year ago, 13 civilian search and rescue organisations cut all operational contact with the Libyan rescue coordination centre in Tripoli, thereby founding the Justice Fleet Alliance. Since then, their rescue ships were blocked 12 times by the Italian government, amounting to more than 300 days of lost operational time. However, Italian courts confirm the alliance's approach: six times, Italian courts set the ships free again shortly after their detention. Six additional blockades are under judicial procedure at the moment, and the alliance is awaiting their verdicts. While some legal proceedings are still ongoing, none has resulted in a final ruling against Justice Fleet members.

Press Release

2026 is the most violent year in the Mediterranean since 2016

A new report by the civil sea rescue organisation Sea-Watch documents 107 violent incidents by Libyan militias against migrants and refugees, as well as European actors in the Mediterranean since 2016. More than 70 per cent of these incidents of extreme violence, 80 in total, were carried out by the so-called Libyan coastguard. The report is being published shortly before the renewal of Germany’s EUNAVFOR MED IRINI mandate. The current version of the mandate contains no clause excluding the training of the so-called Libyan Coast Guard by the German armed forces (Bundeswehr).

Press Release

Frontex ignores rescue ship - but gives Libyan militia the coordinates of a boat in distress

A Frontex aircraft ignored repeated radio calls from the civilian rescue ship Solidaire, then promptly gave a Libyan militia the coordinates of a boat in distress, facilitating the illegal pullback of the people on board. Sea-Watch’s monitoring aircraft Seabird 2 documented the radio exchange in international waters off Libya, as well as the interception that followed. Frontex radio communications also indicate that Frontex staff share their aircraft positions via Telegram. The incident comes just one day after the European Commission proposed the largest expansion of Frontex to date.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Fields marked with * are mandatory.
Transparente Zivilgesellschaft – We are part of the Transparent Civil Society Initiative: our figures and reports
Sea-Watch e.V. – Civil sea rescue at Europe’s bordersThis site is powered by Netlify